How to Compare Heat Pumps: UK 2026 Spec Guide
How to compare heat pumps on SCOP, output, modulation, noise, refrigerant, warranty and grants, plus a six-step method for weighing quotes side by side.
A heat pump comparison that starts with brand names goes wrong fast. Datasheets quote efficiency at different temperatures, noise on different scales and warranties on different conditions, so two units that look a point apart on paper are often level once the numbers are put on the same footing. This guide sets out the eight specs worth comparing, how to normalise each one, and the order to weigh them in when you have two or three quotes on the table.
It covers air-to-water and ground source systems for UK homes. For named brand shortlists, our best heat pumps UK 2026 guide does that job; this page is the method behind any comparison.
What should a heat pump comparison include?
Eight specs, in the order they matter.
SCOP at your design flow temperature
The seasonal efficiency figure, read at 35°C or 55°C to match your emitters.
Output at your design outdoor temperature
Can the unit meet your heat loss on the coldest design day without a backup heater?
Minimum output (modulation floor)
How low the unit can turn down before it starts cycling in mild weather.
Minimum operating temperature
The outdoor temperature at which the unit stops working.
Noise, measured the same way
Sound power against sound power, never against sound pressure.
Refrigerant
R-290 (propane) or R-32, which affects flow temperature range and siting rules.
Warranty terms and their conditions
The headline years against what you must do to keep them.
Grant and finance eligibility
Whether the system type and installer qualify for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme and the Warm Homes Loan.
Why is SCOP the first number to compare?
COP is a snapshot; SCOP is a season.
COP (coefficient of performance, the heat delivered per unit of electricity at one fixed test condition) describes a single moment. SCOP (seasonal coefficient of performance) averages that ratio across a whole heating season, which is why it is the figure to put side by side. OVO puts the UK average SCOP for air source heat pumps at 2.8, which gives a useful floor: a quote modelling well below that deserves a question.
The catch is that every datasheet SCOP is tied to a flow temperature. A unit rated at 35°C (underfloor heating or generously sized radiators) will always look better than the same unit at 55°C. Compare every quote at the flow temperature your heat-loss survey says your home needs, and never one unit at 35°C against another at 55°C. Our COP vs SCOP explainer covers the test points in detail.
That real-world data carries a clear lesson. An analysis of the top 20 systems on HeatpumpMonitor, all above SCOP 4.0 over a full year, found most ran at a maximum flow temperature of 45°C or lower, and that system design mattered more than how well insulated the house was. The brand on the box was not the deciding factor. OVO makes the same point: installation quality changes real-world efficiency as much as the unit rating does.
How do you compare output and sizing?
Match the unit to your heat loss, not to the old boiler.
Every quote should start from a room-by-room heat-loss calculation, and the unit it proposes should meet that figure at your design outdoor temperature. Two 8kW units are not equal if one holds its rated output at -3°C and the other drops below it. Ask each installer for the unit's output at your design temperature and flow temperature, from the manufacturer's capacity tables, rather than the nameplate figure.
Bigger is not safer. An oversized unit spends mild autumn and spring days switching on and off, which wastes energy and wears the compressor. Our guide to heat pump oversizing explains why, and the heat-loss survey guide covers what a proper survey includes.
Why does minimum output matter as much as maximum?
The modulation floor decides mild-weather efficiency.
Minimum output, the lowest level a heat pump can turn down to, is the spec most comparisons leave out. Most UK heating hours fall in mild weather, when a home needs only a few kilowatts. A unit whose floor sits above that demand cannot run continuously, so it cycles on and off instead. Cycling lowers efficiency and adds wear.
When comparing two units of similar maximum output, the one that turns down further suits a well-insulated home better. Manufacturers publish this in their technical data as a minimum capacity at a given outdoor and flow temperature; ask the installer to show it for both units at around 7°C outdoor.
What minimum operating temperatures do UK heat pumps reach?
Every mainstream unit clears UK winters with room to spare.
Minimum operating temperature is the outdoor temperature below which a unit shuts down. For the UK it rarely separates the shortlist, but it is worth confirming for exposed or upland sites. Published limits for popular models, as compiled by Expertsure from manufacturer data:
Published minimum operating temperatures
- Samsung EHS Mono HT Quiet
- -30°C (full capacity to -25°C)
- Daikin Altherma 3 H HT F
- -28°C
- Vaillant aroTHERM plus
- -25°C
- Mitsubishi Ecodan
- -25°C
- Nibe air source range
- -25°C
- Grant Aerona3
- -20°C
- Panasonic Aquarea T-CAP
- -20°C
The figure that matters more is output at your design temperature, covered above. A unit that keeps running at -25°C but loses a third of its output at -5°C is a worse fit than one with a higher cut-off that holds its capacity. Our cold weather operation guide covers defrost cycles and what happens in a cold snap.
How do you compare heat pump noise fairly?
Sound power and sound pressure are different measurements.
Noise figures are where datasheet comparisons go most wrong. Sound power (dB(A) LWA) is a property of the unit itself. Sound pressure is what a listener hears at a stated distance, and it is always a lower number. Daikin quotes outdoor sound pressure for the Altherma 3 range (43-48 dB(A) on the H HT F), while most rivals quote sound power, so the numbers cannot be lined up directly.
Put every unit on sound power, at the same operating mode, before comparing. Noise also bears on planning: permitted development rules for air source heat pumps in England include a noise assessment at the nearest neighbour, which the installer carries out as part of the MCS design. Our heat pump noise levels guide lines up six popular models on a common basis.
Does the refrigerant matter when you compare heat pumps?
Yes, for two reasons. Refrigerant sets the flow temperatures a unit reaches comfortably, and it affects where the outdoor unit can be sited. Newer units increasingly use R-290 (propane, a natural refrigerant with very low global warming potential), as the Vaillant aroTHERM plus does. R-32 remains common, including on the Daikin Altherma 3.
R-290 units reach higher flow temperatures more efficiently, which helps homes keeping existing radiators. Because propane is flammable, R-290 units carry clearance rules around drains, windows and openings. Neither refrigerant is a reason on its own to choose a unit, but it is a fair tie-breaker between two otherwise similar quotes.
What should you check in heat pump warranties?
Read the conditions, not the headline years.
Warranty lengths look generous until you read the conditions. Daikin's standard cover is 2 years, rising to 5 if the installer registers the unit and to 7 with a paid extension and annual servicing. Vaillant's cover beyond 2 years depends on the installer's accreditation tier and on servicing. In both cases, the long warranty depends on the installer and on you keeping up a service plan.
When comparing quotes, write down for each: the warranty term you will actually get from this installer, who registers the unit, the annual service cost needed to keep it, and separately the installer's own workmanship guarantee. Our heat pump servicing guide sets out typical service costs.
Keep our heat pump glossary open while comparing datasheets - it explains each term in plain English.
How do air source and ground source heat pumps compare?
The type decision comes before the model decision. Ground source systems cost far more to install: The Eco Experts puts them at £24,000 to £49,000 against around £10,000 for air source. In return, ground temperature is steadier, so efficiency holds up better through winter, and the system lasts about 25 years, roughly five more than air source. Ground source also needs garden space for horizontal loops or a 90-160m borehole.
For most UK homes air source wins on cost; ground source earns its place on large, high-demand properties with land. Our air source vs ground source guide runs through the trade-offs.
Air source vs ground source at a glance
- Installed cost
- Air: around £10,000 · Ground: £24,000-£49,000
- Lifespan
- Air: about 20 years · Ground: about 25 years
- Winter efficiency
- Ground source steadier, as ground temperature varies less than air
- Space needed
- Air: wall or ground pad · Ground: garden trenches or a 90-160m borehole
- BUS grant
- £7,500 for either; £9,000 replacing oil or LPG
Do grants and finance change the comparison?
Check eligibility before you compare prices.
Grant eligibility belongs in the comparison, because a quote that does not qualify is effectively thousands of pounds dearer. Under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS, the government grant in England and Wales), air-to-water and ground source systems attract £7,500, air-to-air systems £2,500, and hybrid systems nothing. From 21 July 2026 until March 2027, the grant rises to £9,000 where the heat pump replaces oil or LPG in an off-gas-grid home.
Every BUS installation must meet the MCS 007 v8.0 and MIS 3005-D v3.0 standards, so check that each installer is MCS certified for the system they are quoting. The UK-wide Warm Homes Loan, launched on 27 October 2026, adds no- and low-interest loans of up to £20,000 for air-to-water, £10,000 for air-to-air and £35,000 for ground source, and it can be combined with a BUS grant. See our Boiler Upgrade Scheme guide and finance options guide for the detail.
How do you compare heat pump quotes side by side?
A six-step method for two or three quotes.
Check the heat-loss figure
Every quote should state your home's heat loss in kW. If two quotes differ widely, ask each to show the calculation before going further.
Normalise SCOP
Ask for the SCOP each unit achieves at the design flow temperature in its own design, not the brochure best case.
Confirm output and the modulation floor
Output at your design outdoor temperature, and minimum output at around 7°C outdoor, for each unit.
Put noise on one scale
Sound power for every unit, plus the result of the installer's noise assessment at your nearest neighbour.
List what the price includes
Radiator upgrades, cylinder, electrical work, removal of the old boiler, and commissioning. Missing items are the usual reason one quote looks cheaper.
Compare the net cost and the warranty you keep
Price after the BUS grant, the warranty term this installer can register, and the annual service cost needed to keep it.
Our guide to vetting an MCS heat pump installer covers the installer side of the comparison, which on the evidence above matters at least as much as the unit. For model-against-model weigh-ups, see Mitsubishi Ecodan vs Daikin Altherma 3 and Vaillant vs Viessmann.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important spec when comparing heat pumps?
Is a higher SCOP always better?
Can I compare heat pump noise figures from different brands?
Does the brand matter when comparing heat pumps?
Which heat pumps qualify for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme?

Best Heat Pumps UK 2026

Heat Pump COP vs SCOP

Heat Pump Noise Levels UK 2026
